Which: Leader, Trainer, or Coach?

3 woman are sitting at a table and talking.
3 woman are sitting at a table and talking.
Which- Leader, Trainer, or Coach?

Often these roles are confused or used interchangeably when they are actually very different. Each serves a unique purpose.  Following are definitions, simple how to outlines for each role, a short list of what happens with each role, and questions considered for each role.

LEADER

A leader shares vision, gives direction, provides resources and tools to their team, motivates, and recognizes.

How to Be a Leader
•       Be Confident and Knowledge
•       Be Firm and Kind
•       Be Decisive
•       Give and Earn Respect and Trust
•       Be a Visionary
•       Be a Motivator
•       Manage Accountability

What Happens in Leading:
•       A leader develops or communicates the vision.
•       A leader makes decisions.
•       A leader inspires people to act.
•       A leader motivates follow-through.

The Leader Asks Them Self:
•       How does the requested change align with the vision?
•       How does this change improve operations?
•       What is the impact of the change?
•       Who are the stakeholders?
•       How capable is the person who will lead the change?
•       How will accountability be managed?

TRAINER

A trainer facilitates a person learning and improving a particular skill or a type of behavior.

How to Be a Trainer
•       Learn training methodologies and processes for sharing knowledge, assessing retention, and supporting application.
•       Develop expertise with the subject matter.
•       Determine what is to be learned by assessing skill gap.
•       Design the training experience.
•       Deliver the training.
•       Assess learning.

What Happens in Training:
•       The trainer assesses the skills gap.
•       The trainer designs the learning to include teaching and practicing skills.
•       The trainer assesses through observation, testing, evaluating, etc.
•       The trainer provides feedback.

The Trainer Asks Them Self:
•       What is the skills gap?
•       How do I know that for sure?
•       What do I have to offer?
•       How do I best support skill development?
•       How will I know when the trainee is competent?
•       How can training help this person?
•       What is the best way to train?

COACH

Coaching is partnering with clients in a thought-provoking and creative process that inspires them to maximize their personal and professional potential.   – International Coaching Federation

How to Be a Coach:
•       Become a coach with training/certification.
•       Co-create the process.
•       Client determines focus, goals, and action steps.
•       Coach asks questions and facilitates growth.

What Happens in Coaching:
•       The coach asks open-ended questions focused on the client so they:
•       Define Goals
•       Consider Challenges
•       Identify Resources
•       Create Actions Steps
•       Develop Accountability
•       Celebrate Progress and Success

The Coach Asks Them Self:
•       What questions can I ask my client to help them come to their own conclusion(s)?
•       How can I partner with them effectively, so they expand their thinking and create their strategies?
•       How can I support my client in developing their personal accountability?
•       How can I support them to be their best self?

The paradox is that coaching can be used when leading or training while leading and training CANNOT be used when coaching.

Cathy Liska

For content specific to coach training and coaching, guest blog posts are welcome.

Most blog posts here are written or curated by Cathy Liska, Guide from the Side®, CDP, MCC.

Cathy is CEO/Founder of the Center for Coaching Certification, CCC. As Guide from the Side®, she is a sought-after trainer and coach with over 30 years of experience in business management and ownership. Cathy built her diverse team at CCC that includes trainers, customer service, and coaches. She was Co-Leader for ICF’s Ethics Community of Practice, on the Leadership Team for the review and updating of the Code of Ethics in 2024, and active in the Ethics Water Cooler. To ensure she stays current in related areas of expertise, Cathy has earned the following: ICF’s Master Certified Coach (MCC), Certified Coach Trainer, Certified Consumer Credit Counselor, Certificate of Excellence in Nonprofit Leadership and Management, Grief Support Group Facilitator, Certified in the Drucker Self-Assessment Tool, Certified Apartment Manager, Certified Civil and Family Mediator, and Certified in DISC.

Cathy’s clients range from attorneys to corporate executives, government to nonprofit, entrepreneurs to children, under or unemployed to newly retired. She specializes in communication, management, conflict, and leadership. Her personal mission statement is “People.” Cathy is known for her passion to serve others so they achieve the results they want.

Podcast: https://www.coachcert.com/podcast.html

Publications: Coaching Perspectives (a series of books with chapters by coach training graduates) https://www.coachcert.com/resources/recommended-reading/coaching-perspectives-series-by-the-center-for-coaching-certification-and-more.html

You may also like...